Oil and natural gas prices traveled divergent paths this week, resulting in a mixed picture for the Club stocks Coterra Energy (CTRA) and Pioneer Natural Resources (PXD). Fresh off robust third-quarter gains, crude has tumbled in recent days, sending the U.S. oil benchmark West Texas Intermediate and global oil standard Brent prices to their lowest levels since late August. Both WTI and Brent are on pace for their worst weeks since March on emergent concerns about demand for oil products. WTI dropped 2% on Thursday to settle at $82.31 a barrel. Brent also fell 2%, settling at $84.07 a barrel. On Friday, they bounced — coming off modest earlier declines after the government released much stronger-than-expected September job growth. WTI vs. nat gas this week @CL.1 @NG.1 mountain 2023-09-29 WTI and nat gas since Sept. 29 settle Meanwhile, the rally in natural gas has picked up steam, pushing the commodity to prices not seen since January, at over $3 per million British thermal units, or MMBtu. In Thursday’s session alone, natural gas prices jumped nearly 7%, as traders reacted to U.S. government data that showed a smaller-than-expected storage build. Traders also continue to monitor weather forecasts in search of clues about future demand heading into the winter months in the Northern Hemisphere. For the week, through Thursday’s settle, natural gas has climbed 8.1%, building on last week’s 11% advance. Natural gas on Friday morning jumped another 1.5%. In the oil market, a switch has seemingly been flipped. WTI and Brent rose more than 28% and 27%, respectively, in the third quarter, as major oil exporters Saudi Arabia and Russia cut production at a time when economic activity — and by extension demand for crude – proved more resilient than expected. Now, the market is grappling with the idea that demand might be waning. Those concerns were amplified by U.S. government data Wednesday that indicated gasoline inventories in the week ended Sept. 29 grew by 6.48 million barrels, a much higher increase than expected. WTI and Brent each plunged by 5.6% in Wednesday’s session. For the week, with one trading day to go, WTI and Brent sank more than 9% and nearly 12%, respectively. “The single biggest element of the global oil market is U.S. gasoline. We consume not far off 1 in 10 barrels just in U.S. cars,” veteran energy analyst Paul Sankey said Thursday on CNBC. “When it’s as weak as it came in [Wednesday] and it already been weak the week before, it becomes a major problem in the global oil market.” The magnitude of the sell-off, Sankey said, is linked to the traders who had been rushing into crude during its summertime ascent that continued into September , raising the specter of $100 per barrel oil . Brent traded as high as $97.69 a barrel on Sept. 28 while WTI reached $95.03 on the same day. Recent data has traders looking to reduce their risk, Sankey said. “The speculative interest before this run was very low,” he said. “Our view was that our shot at $100 was that speculators would pile in. The problem is … risk-off turned into [really} risk-off, and that became the speculators running for the exits again.” Some analysts see the oil swoon as temporary. In a note to clients Thursday, Goldman Sachs said the reasons for the declines — which in addition to gasoline demand concerns also include recession fears in 2024 and technical factors — “will prove to be transitory.” The firm said it still believes Brent crude can reach $100 a barrel by the spring. The recent decline in crude has hurt energy stocks including Pioneer and Coterra. Of the 11 sectors in the S & P 500 , energy has been by far the worst weekly performer through Thursday, falling nearly 6%. The broad S & P 500 index was down 0.7% over the past four sessions. Shares of Pioneer have retreated 6.4% over the same stretch, closing at $214.96 each Thursday. However, Pioneer’s weekly losses will be erased if the stock’s premarket surge of 10% holds. Friday’s spike higher came after The Wall Street Journal reported Exxon Mobil (XOM) was in advanced talks to acquire the Club holding. In April, the newspaper reported Exon held “informal” discussions on Pioneer. Pioneer vs. Coterra this week PXD CTRA mountain 2023-09-29 Pioneer vs. Coterra since Sept. 29 close Coterra held up better this week through Thursday, with the stock falling 3.5%, to $26.11 per share. The stock was little changed in Friday’s premarket. The relative outperformance in Coterra is likely tied to its significant natural gas exposure, compared with Pioneer and exploration-and-production (E & P) peers such as Diamondback Energy (FANG) and former Club holding Devon Energy (DVN). Coterra’s revenues are roughly a 50-50 split between oil and natural gas. On Monday, when we bought 200 more shares of Coterra, we argued its stock did not adequately reflect the appreciation in natural gas prices. Now, the stock has slipped a bit lower than where we bought while natural gas has climbed higher. (Jim Cramer’s Charitable Trust is long PXD and CTRA. See here for a full list of the stocks.) As a subscriber to the CNBC Investing Club with Jim Cramer, you will receive a trade alert before Jim makes a trade. Jim waits 45 minutes after sending a trade alert before buying or selling a stock in his charitable trust’s portfolio. If Jim has talked about a stock on CNBC TV, he waits 72 hours after issuing the trade alert before executing the trade. THE ABOVE INVESTING CLUB INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO OUR TERMS AND CONDITIONS AND PRIVACY POLICY , TOGETHER WITH OUR DISCLAIMER . NO FIDUCIARY OBLIGATION OR DUTY EXISTS, OR IS CREATED, BY VIRTUE OF YOUR RECEIPT OF ANY INFORMATION PROVIDED IN CONNECTION WITH THE INVESTING CLUB. NO SPECIFIC OUTCOME OR PROFIT IS GUARANTEED.
Oil and natural gas prices traveled divergent paths this week, resulting in a mixed picture for the Club stocks Coterra Energy (CTRA) and Pioneer Natural Resources (PXD).